What’s The Difference: Protein Bars Vs Protein Shakes

If you’re looking to up your protein intake. Then you’ve probably considered either taking some protein bar or protein shake to help get you to your goals.

A few of the differences between protein bars vs protein shakes typically are the price point, convenience, quality of protein, taste, satiety, and texture of the product you are using. Each has its own benefits and disadvantages.

Below, I’ll talk in more detail about the advantages of using protein bars and the advantages when it comes to using protein shakes. It’s up to you to decide which one is better for your protein intake needs and what protein supplement you want to go with.

Protein Bar With Granola And Fruit

The Advantages of Protein Bars

Protein bars have plenty of advantages over protein powders (aka protein shakes). Below, I’ve listed the major advantages of using protein bars in your diet.

More Filling

In the protein bars vs protein shakes debate. A protein bar tends to be more filling and can keep you satiated longer than your typical protein shake. (satiated is a fancy word for keeping you full longer.)

Protein shakes are usually just water with powder added. But a protein bar can contain real whole foods like dried fruit, nuts, or granola.

These ingredients help make protein bars more filling than a shake typically would. (I say typically because there are ways to make shakes more filling, which I’ll get to later in this blog post.)

Carbs Fat Protein Knobs

Protein Bars Have Different Macronutrients

Another advantage is that protein bars have a different macronutrient balance than protein shakes. You can get whey protein which is pretty much just pure protein low in fats and carbs.

However, a protein bar tends to have higher fats and carbs compared to their protein shake (protein powder) counterparts.

And this can be a good thing if it aligns with your fitness goals. But it can also be a disadvantage at the same time if it doesn’t align with your goals.

Protein Bars May Be Less Processed

You can bet that protein powder is a very processed food. (There is nothing wrong with that.) But if you are trying to avoid processed foods. Then protein bars may be the better solution.

A protein bar with nuts, granola, and dried fruit has more whole foods than a powder that’s been highly processed.

But keep in mind some protein bars have processed ingredients in them as well, and some even use protein powders to increase the amount of protein in their products

Calories And Nutrients Chart

Contains Other Nutrients

Another benefit of protein bars is that they usually contain other nutrients that are good for you when you eat them. This can be from the vitamins and minerals of some of the ingredients they use to create their products, like nuts, fruit, etc.

Convenience Of Protein Bars

One of the best advantages a protein bar has over protein shakes is its convenience. You do not need any liquid to mix with them. You don’t have to carry around a shaker bottle.

All you need to do is grab your protein bar. Stuff it in your bag, and eat whenever you feel the need to. So I’d say protein bars win the convenience category between these two powerhouses.

Now let’s talk about the other side of protein supplements…

Protein Shake With Yellow Background

The Advantages Of Protein Shakes

Below are some of the advantages of protein shakes and what you should keep in mind when choosing which product is better for you and your fitness goals.

Protein Powder Is Usually A Leaner Option

Protein powder is usually the leaner option when it comes to the battle between protein bars and protein shakes.

1 scoop of protein can have around 20 grams of protein and only contain 120 calories.

And a majority of those macros are coming from just protein. This is really helpful and gives you more control of your diet, especially if you are counting macros or trying to hit certain protein intake goals.

Create More Options Note

More Flexibility With Protein Powder

Another benefit of protein shakes over protein bars is the fact that you have more flexibility when it comes to protein powders. (if you are making protein shakes, then chances are you have protein powder that you can mess around with.)

For example, you can create protein shakes that are more filling by making a smoothie. Adding milk, fruits, and yogurt to your drink can change the taste or the form of how you want to consume your protein.

Besides making protein shakes. You can make recipes and meals with your protein powder, like protein ice cream or protein pancakes.

This gives you more flexibility to enjoy your protein powders and is a big advantage to those who get tired of drinking the same protein shake or protein bars over and over again.

Girl Smiling With Calculator

Protein Shakes Tend To Be Budget Friendly

When you are purchasing a tub of protein powder, it is usually a lot more affordable than buying protein bars. Not all Protein bars are expensive, but the majority can cost anywhere from $3-$5 per bar.

And usually, an average protein shake can be made for much less. Sometimes even as low as $1 per serving of protein.

So, if budgeting is your thing, I think protein shakes are the more budget-friendly option between the two.

Choose Better Quality Protein

You have the option to choose better quality protein when it comes to making your protein shakes. You can choose to isolate, whey protein, or casein protein.

This is a big advantage, especially when you don’t know exactly what type of protein is being used in some of the protein bars you might be buying.

Make sure to keep this in mind if the type of protein you are using is important to you and your goals.

Can protein bars replace protein shakes?

In my opinion, these two can be used interchangeably. If protein shakes are better for you and your goals, go with that option. Or if protein bars are better for your situation or you just prefer them over shakes, then go with that option.

At the end of the day, protein is protein. Whether you get it through whole food sources, or you can use protein bars and a protein shake to hit your protein goals. It is completely up to you, your budget, your taste buds, and what is more convenient for you.

Girl Looking At Salad Or Cake

What To Look For In Protein Bars Vs Protein Shakes

Now, let’s talk about what to look for when buying protein bars or a protein powder for your shakes. This section might just be a preference, but I leave it up to you to decide.

What To Look For In A Protein Bar

When choosing which protein bars to go with. You want to ensure that what you buy is not a glorified candy bar.

Make sure you look at the nutrition label of the protein bars you are planning to purchase. And ensure there is a decent amount of protein in the bar, and they are fairly low in fat and sugars.

Some companies advertise candy bars as protein bars because they just have a little protein content. So be sure to keep an eye out for this.

Male Looking At Blue Shaker Bottle

What To Look For In A Protein Shake

When shopping around for a protein shake, you will have a bunch of different things you can consider, like the type of protein, flavor, etc.

But the main thing you want to look for in a protein shake is probably the type of protein. And keep in mind your goals with this powder. Are you using it for protein shakes, or do you plan to cook with it?

Different types of protein are better for cooking, and each type of protein will give you a different type of consistency when it comes to your protein shakes, so keep that in mind.

Casein protein tends to be thick, Whey protein is the standard texture, I’d say, and isolate can have a very watery consistency, almost like juice.

Girl Deciding Between Red Or Blue Shoe

Which Is Better, Protein Bar Or Protein Powder

This question really depends on your fitness goals, taste buds, preferences, and budget.

As far as protein supplements go. You can use either in your diet to help you hit your protein goals. Both products will help with muscle protein synthesis. Whether you’re trying to put muscle mass or lean down

I always recommend trying to get most of your protein through whole food ingredients, but protein supplements can help when you need a little boost.

But take a look at the benefits of protein bars and the benefits of protein shakes I’ve listed above.

Go through and decide which one will be better for you from a taste, texture, convenience, and budget standpoint.

Then go with what you decide. You can always change your mind and use both or try the other out later.

Conclusion For Protein Bars Vs Protein Shakes

That’s it for this blog post. I hope you’ve found out everything you need to know when it comes to protein bars and protein shakes. What are the differences between the two products?

This should give you a better understanding of what is suitable for you and your goals. Because at the end of the day, it really will boil down to preference.

Some people prefer to eat protein bars because of their convenience. Some people like the flexibility of protein powder and protein shakes. There isn’t a right or wrong answer here. Just go with which one feels right for you.

And you can even use both of them too if you really want to.

But keep in mind it’s important to eat solid food. Getting protein from chewing solid food should be your first option. Then, you can supplement with protein here and there to help with your goals.

Thank you again for being here on my blog. I hope you learned a lot and got value from this post. If you did, I ask you to share it with 1 person you think will find this valuable too!

I’ll see you in the next post!

Jordan Arenas

My name is Jordan Arenas and I am the owner and author of RFKN Fit. I created RFKN Fit to help others achieve their fitness goals. My mission is to share helpful workouts, nutrition tips, delicious recipes, tips on mindset, some motivation, and some good ol' gym humor with this blog of mine. Hope you enjoy!

Recent Posts